The Vital Importance of User Experience: Lessons from Three Mile Island
Written on
Chapter 1: The Three Mile Island Incident
The catastrophic nuclear accident at Three Mile Island in 1979 serves as a stark reminder of the critical role user experience plays in design. This incident, marked by human error intertwined with design flaws, emphasizes the necessity of prioritizing user experience in all fields.
“Thinking about design is hard, but not thinking about it can be disastrous.”
—Ralph Caplan
Section 1.1: The Incident Unfolds
On March 28, 1979, a partial meltdown occurred at the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant, marking the most serious nuclear incident in the United States. Rated a level 5 on the International Nuclear Event Scale, the event unfolded when operators attempted to resolve a blockage in a condensate polisher, a common issue typically addressed with ease. Unfortunately, their standard method using compressed air failed, unbeknownst to them.
A small amount of water, pushed by compressed air, entered an instrument air line, leading to a series of mechanical failures and an emergency shutdown late that night. The operators' inadequate training and the plant's protocols left them ill-prepared for the escalating crisis.
Section 1.2: The Design Flaws
The design of the control room significantly contributed to the chaos. Operators faced a daunting 25-meter control panel, cluttered with 1,100 knobs and switches and 600 warning lights, all going off simultaneously. Imagine the overwhelming noise and flashing lights, making it nearly impossible to discern the source of the problem.
During this emergency, operators had to consult procedural guidelines to ensure compliance, but the control panel's design made the situation even more confusing, creating a domino effect of unpredictable consequences. The human-machine interaction design was a key factor leading to the disaster.
Chapter 2: Learning from the Past
The lessons from the Three Mile Island incident resonate deeply within the field of user experience. The challenges faced by the plant operators mirror those encountered by everyday users of technology and software.
When designing for others, it’s essential to empathize with their experiences and understand their thought processes. The most peculiar human actions often stem from underlying reasons. By grasping human behavior, we can create products that genuinely meet user needs, considering their thought patterns and limitations.
Interesting Fact
Don Norman, who led the investigation following the accident, highlighted the design issues within the control room. For further insights into the significance of user experience, consider reading his book, “The Design of Everyday Things.”
The first video titled "My First UX Case Study With No Experience Example & Tips" discusses practical examples and tips for conducting UX case studies even without prior experience.
The second video "How to create a UX case study with no UX experience (unhinged explanation)" provides an unfiltered view of creating a UX case study, making it accessible for beginners.
Literature
Follow us on:
- Olga’s LinkedIn
- Kuba’s LinkedIn
Originally published on our website: cxperiencelab.com
If you want to learn more, read the articles below:
- Tailoring Customer Experience: Savile Row’s Lessons for Success
- Navigating UX Research on a Budget: Maximizing Insights without Breaking the Bank